Skip to main content

This is Not a Wall (Essay)

Distributed to the Friends of Friendship Park, March, 2009

My new friend, who works for the Border Patrol, resists my use of the word “wall” to describe the vast system of barriers being erected along the length of the U.S.-Mexico border. He would prefer that I – and others who oppose current U.S. border policy – talk about the barriers by referring to them as “tactical infrastructure.”

Here is a picture of Jill Holslin standing in front of the second barrier that cuts across several miles of the San Diego-Tijuana urban corridor.


PLEASE NOTE: This is Not a Wall

And here is a picture, taken from the top of the metal fence that marks the international boundary, of the second barrier that now spans the western-most 3.5 miles of the border. This barrier cuts through the Tijuana Estuary and Border Field State Park at a distance ranging from 150 feet to 800 feet north of the border:


PLEASE NOTE: This is Not a Wall


Finally, here is a line of vehicles and Border Patrol agents that now prevent public access to Friendship Park, the historic border park where for generations people from San Diego and Tijuana have gathered to visit with friends and family through the border fence:


PLEASE NOTE: This is Not a Wall


When people try to access the border fence, this is what they come up against:


PLEASE NOTE: This is Not a Wall


On February 21 Dan Watman and I were detained and then released for contesting this barrier. (Watch the 6-minute video.) On March 1 we met with a similar fate and a Border Patrol agent threatened Nick Correte, a member of our group who happened to be on crutches, with a blast from a pepper-spray gun. (Watch the 2-minute video.) On recent Sunday afternoons, informal gatherings of people on the beach near Friendship Park have been met in a similar fashion.

So what are we to make of this? Clearly, the policy of prohibiting public access to the border fence is now in full effect. The U.S. land adjacent to the border – all 1,969 miles of it – has now been federalized and declared off limits to U.S. citizens. Any who would try to access the borderlands from the north are now met with the same strategies that Border Patrol agents use to prevent Mexican nationals (and others) from crossing the border from the south. (I don’t blame the agents for this – they are now being asked to carry out work which is outside their true mission and for which they have not been properly trained.)

What we are witnessing is another epochal transformation of the U.S.-Mexico borderlands. In the early 20th century, what was once wide-open “frontier” was marked with a “line.” In the second half of the 20th century, this line had a “fence” built on it. And now, in the early decades of the 21st century, north of the border fence, a “wall” is being erected.

Oops! Sorry, I forgot: THIS IS NOT A WALL.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

THE HUBRIS OF INCLUSION: Thoughts on the Future of the United Methodist Church

The United Methodist Church was born in a specific time and place, in the mid-twentieth century in the United States of America. Protestant denominations were ascendant, and with them a brand of "ecumenism" that would only decades later be recognized by those who championed it as culturally bound to the white "mainline." Mergers were all the buzz, including the one that created the UMC in 1968, and Methodists embraced their new denomination as partial fulfillment of a dream of "Christian unity." As the historian Robert Handy noted in his wonderful little 1971 book,  A Christian America: Protestant Hopes and Historical Realities , leaders of the new denomination thought of it as "a kind of unofficial national church." Because they sat at the midpoint of mainline American Protestantism in so many respects -- ecclesial, theological, liturgical -- it was easy for them to assume that as all churches became one, pretty much everyone else would eventua...

Methodism's Many Pasts and Futures

From the time the brothers John and Charles Wesley first convened a "holy club" of friends at Oxford University in 1729, Methodists have declared theirs a pursuit of “holiness” or “Christian perfection.”  For early Methodists, the pursuit of Christian perfection led inevitably to disagreements about what it meant to live a holy life.   As early as  1741 the Wesleys distanced themselves from their closest collaborator, George Whitefield, over his Calvinist teachings.  And while Wesley proclaimed himself to possess "a catholic spirit," his practices - not least, his own refusal to conform to the conventions of Anglican parish ministry - were widely perceived by his contemporaries to be divisive or even "schismatic." Methodism on the other side of the Atlantic retained this same spirit, which should come as little surprise since it was born in an act of separation - in 1784,  Wesley consecrated Thomas Coke as Superintendent, setting in motion the cre...

On the 40th Anniversary of Friendship Park

Imagine the First Lady of the United States punching a hole in the fence on the U.S.-Mexico border.   Imagine her publicly lamenting that there was a border fence at all. In fact this scenario doesn’t need to be imagined … because it happened forty years ago right here in San Diego County.   The date was August 18, 1971 and the location was “Friendship Park,” the small cement plaza on the U.S.-Mexico border, at the southwest-most corner of the continental United States. The First Lady was Pat Nixon, who had been a prominent champion of our state’s public parks when her husband Richard Nixon was Governor of California, before being elected President of the United States.    She came to Friendship Park to inaugurate the surrounding area as California’s Border Field State Park.    After planting a tree as part of the inauguration ceremony, Mrs. Nixon approached the large stone monument which sits at the heart of Friendship Park.   The monument commemo...